Friday, 7 May 2010

Research - Genre Comparative Study

A Day To Remember – The Plot To Bomb Panhandle


Fei Comodo – Riot To Remember


A similarity between the two videos is that they both show the band playing. This is a generic convention of the metal genre in music videos, as the the skill of the musicians is an important part of the music. It is normal for the band to play in a setting that it would be unusual to perform in. For example in the A Day To Remember (ADTR) video, the band are performing in a dojo. However in the Fei Comodo video the band are playing in what looks like a practise room and at a concert, where it is normal for a band to play in these settings. This is a difference between the two videos, yet it still follows the generic conventions of the genre.

Another way in which both bands similarly follow the conventions of the genre is that they are both performing for audiences. The audience in the Fei Comodo video are watching the band play via webcam and watching at a concert and it appears that ADTR are playing for the people in the video to dance to.

Another similarity between the videos is in mise-en-scene as both the bands are dressed in normal casual clothes and have not dressed up in anything. This is because this is the style in which metal bands tend to present themselves in, although there are plenty where the band dress up as well, for example

There is intertextuality in the Fei Comodo video as it shows the “Nokia” label on a phone, but other than that there is no other reference to other texts. The only intertextuality reference visible on the ADTR video is the label of the amplifiers used which is “Ampeg” and the make of the bass drum, “Shine”, is made visible. Also the teacher in the video is Ron Jeremy, who is a famous porn star. In music videos other celebrities tend to feature occasionally, for example Ron Jeremy has also had a short appearance in the “10 Miles Wide” music video for “Escape The Fate” along with videos for other bands.

A difference between the videos is the reference to voyeurism is different. The Fei Comodo video shows the band being watched on televisions, a phone, on computer screens and by an audience at a concert. It is normal in the genre to sometimes be shown playing on a screen of some sort. It is also extremely typical of the genre for the band to be shown playing live in front of an audience. However the ADTR video does not show much voyeurism at all in the aspect of an audience watching and it is only at the end where people begin to watch and get involved with the band. However there is voyeurism in other ways shown such as the band's reflection in the mirror can be seen. Another way in which voyeurism is shown is the pupils watching the teacher and the teacher watching the pupils. This shows as a difference between the videos as it shows voyeurism in different ways, yet it is a similarity too as it still shows reference to looking.

Another similarity is that there are links between the lyrics and the visuals. In the ADTR video when singing the line “It's proved I can't trust a word you say”, the singer points at the camera when he sings “you” as if he is saying it directly to whoever is watching the video. This also occurs in the second verse in the line “Try to pretend I never even knew your name” as the singer again points at the camera when he sings “you”. In addition to this the way the singer puts his words across is effected by the lyrics he is singing in the first chorus. During the line “I can't believe I stayed so unhappy for so long, where did I go wrong?” he comes across as quite downbeat in comparison to the rest of the song where he is jumping around and comes across as upbeat. There is also emphasis of certain words, for example in the first line of the song, “I've learned to let go”, the word “go” is emphasised as lights come on as it is said. The Fei Comodo video also has an example of links between lyrics and visuals but to a far lesser extent as it only occurs once in the line “and make up our minds” where the singer points to his head whilst singing.

In addition to this, there are links between the music and the visuals. One of these is in the ADTR video where Ron Jeremy appears to start teaching at the start of the first verse. This shows that there is a link between the structure of the song and video. Also in the bridge between the first chorus and second verse there is emphasis put on the end and start of the bars. The first is example occurs at 1minute 40seconds where the guitarist swings his guitar around and the second is at 1minute 50seconds where Ron Jeremy does a spinning kick. Also there is a link again at the start of the second verse as that is the same point where the class begin getting taught to 2-step. Following this structure, the class come over by the band and form a mosh pit during the breakdown at the end and after the music stops playing, Ron Jeremy claps which also shows it is the end of the song. On the other hand the Fei Comodo video does not show many links between music and visuals like the ADTR video. There is one link which shows the structure of the song and that is during the chorus it only shows the band playing, along with cuts back to the webcam, and does not show any of the other people that are shown in other parts of the song.

Both videos meet the label's demands as they both show plenty of the band's faces and plenty of them playing. The videos mainly focus on the singers of the bands but also show a lot of the other band members too. This is consistent in both videos.

No comments:

Post a Comment